Conservancy News

Your support empowered the successful advocacy to stop the City Hall murals from being covered. Santa Monica Cultural Affairs staff is moving ahead with community outreach and engagement through the launch of a new initiative, Acknowledge + Reframe Together (Reframe), which will support art and civic memory projects that center community voices with the aim of creating a more just and equitable Santa Monica. The Santa Monica Conservancy encourages your participation.

Photos: Historical Marker Database

In particular, Reframe will focus on centering the voices and experiences of communities of color who have been historically excluded from discourse about representation in Civic spaces. Belmar History + Art (2019-2021) was a demonstration project that inspired this initiative, and Santa Monica Cultural Affairs is now embarking on a public engagement process around the WPA-era murals by Stanton McDonald-Wright in the historic City Hall lobby.

This will include gathering a diverse array of voices and perspectives through a series of community conversations and art activations, with the goal of commissioning new artworks that will convey more of this land’s history and better express our community’s values today.

The survey seeks to learn more about people’s ties to Santa Monica and their reflections on place and belonging. Please respond at the link below to help shape discussions and activities regarding the City Hall murals going forward!

Take the survey online.

On February 22nd, City Council unanimously approved a motion agreeing to the Santa Monica Conservancy’s request to not proceed with covering the historic murals in City Hall.

“Request of Councilmembers de la Torre and Parra that Council directs staff to no longer install a temporary scrim over the Stanton Macdonald-Wright murals in the lobby of Santa Monica City Hall and to instead direct staff to launch of a process that engages and educates our community and results in the addition of artwork within the lobby to create a more inclusive and complete story of our City’s history and vision for our future to advance the City’s commitment to equity, justice and respect for all and, in the interim, direct staff to explore the creation of a temporary lobby display around the themes that will be explored during the larger community education and engagement process.” (See the City Council agenda here.)

Photos: Historical Marker Database

This motion reversed a prior action taken by City Council in May 2021 to cover the murals with a scrim because they were perceived as racist and not reflective of our current values. The Conservancy’s leadership helped to forge this positive outcome by advocating to preserve the murals in City Hall, which are landmarked, and providing education from a historic perspective while endorsing the creation of new information and public art to promote racial justice. To all our members and friends, who wrote letters and emails to City Council to support our position, we thank you – we could not have done it without your support.

Councilmembers de la Torre and Parra thanked the Conservancy for its constructive role and described some of the future ideas to implement their motion: creating new materials to engage children in understanding the themes of the murals and hiring a consultant to steer the community education and involvement process. We will keep you informed of those next steps.

Notable in this controversy was the failure of City staff to use the legal protections of our landmarks ordinance to acknowledge this potentially adverse action, and to refer this matter to the Landmarks Commission. The WPA-era murals by renowned artist Stanton Macdonald-Wright, a Santa Monica resident, were identified as character-defining features of City Hall when the building was designated in 1979 and reaffirmed in numerous City documents subsequently. The Conservancy will need to follow up to ensure that all material and spatial characteristics of City Hall interiors are recognized as having historic significance so that there is no misunderstanding in the future.

If anyone in Santa Monica could be called the quintessential civic organizer, Doris Sosin’s name would readily come to mind. Although she recently passed away, Doris’ considerable imprint on our city leaves a lasting legacy benefiting all who live, work and visit here, not only now but well into the future. Her contributions span many arenas: historic preservation, neighborhood involvement in municipal government, maintenance of the character of our unique beach community, protection of our urban forest, and promotion of arts programming.

Most near and dear to our hearts is the fact that Doris’ co-founded the Santa Monica Conservancy. In 2002 after witnessing the beginning of the wholesale destruction of historic homes in her North of Montana neighborhood, she drew a map of historic homes for sale to demonstrate what the city would stand to lose if these were demolished. She provided the direction and inspiration for the formation of the Conservancy, the first and only local preservation nonprofit in Santa Monica.

Not only did she bring in residents to join, but she also influenced others to share her passion to serve on the board and lay the foundation for our organization which has prospered for 20 years. She was instrumental in helping us establish our Preservation Resource Center in an 1890s shotgun house that had been in imminent danger of demolition. Her immense generosity funded all of the educational resources at the shotgun house – from the educational docent program and free tours to the interpretive displays. And her financial support continues to help the Conservancy embark on a new chapter through the hiring of our first Executive Director.

“Doris had the vision, the connections and the drive to form this preservation organization,” Conservancy President Tom Cleys said. “She was especially gifted at mobilizing the community, motivating people to carry out initiatives, and above all, she really acted – she was a do-er.”

Her passion and concern for maintaining our city also extended to active participation in city-appointed positions: as a member of the Urban Forest Task Force and as a Commissioner on the Recreation and Parks Commission. She regularly appeared before the Landmarks Commission to advocate for historic preservation. Through all these efforts, she mastered the intricate workings of our local government and how to effect change.

Her advocacy included participating in the Santa Monica Coalition for a Livable City, another resident-based nonprofit organization concerned about unsustainable development and transparency in government decision making. She served as a trusted advisor since its formation in 2005.

Her love of the arts was evident in her significant financial support for The Broad Stage from its inaugural season. She enjoyed bringing friends and family to the Broad, especially to student matinees to watch young people experience what was often their first live performance. She regularly supported special performances including one she supported at her home in Playa Vista in her later years.

“I see things popping up all over that young people have started. These marvelous [movements] to save the things we care about. So, I think the future comes from the children, from the young people, and that they’re fighters. They also want to make a better world. I think there’s a lot of hope in that.”

 

We are seeking nominations for our 2022 Preservation Awards, which will be announced at our Annual Meeting in late spring. Each year we honor exemplary projects and contributors to the preservation of Santa Monica’s architectural and cultural heritage.

The American Colonial Revival-style courtyard apartments at 423- 429 Ocean Avenue, which are a historic landmark, was awarded a 2021 Rehabilitation Award. Photo: David Kaplan / Santa Monica Conservancy

Since 2004, award-winning projects have included residences as well as commercial and institutional buildings of all sizes. These projects have entailed restoration, renovation, rehabilitation and adaptive reuse as well as additions to historic buildings and homes. Awards are also presented to individuals for their stewardship of historic properties as well as for community service as volunteers and advocates of preservation.

To nominate a project, person, structure or group for a 2022 Preservation Award, please download the 2022 Preservation Award Nomination Form and email it to [email protected]. Include the name of the project or person and provide a brief statement about your nomination. The deadline for nominations is March 14, 2022. View all of our past awards here!

With issues of racial inequity and social justice at the forefront of our national consciousness, Santa Monica City Hall’s historic murals have come under criticism for not reflecting our contemporary values. Two proposals have advanced in City Council – one to cover the murals from public view, the other to recontextualize them with new interpretive material and additional artwork reflecting new perspectives on our difficult history. The Conservancy opposes covering the historic murals in our landmark City Hall, but we enthusiastically support the recontextualization goals. The opportunity to deepen the thematic content of the murals without censoring them would be a beneficial outcome of the current debate.

In that spirit, the Conservancy presented The City Hall Murals, a free webinar in our Santa Monica Mosaic series, on Sunday, January 23. Watch the recording of our event and explore the cultural themes of the History and Recreation murals, both in their original context as WPA artworks and as viewed from contemporary perspectives.

Featured speakers:

Art historian Will South is the foremost authority on mural artist Stanton Macdonald-Wright. His Ph.D. dissertation culminated in the exhibition and publication Color, Myth & Music: Stanton Macdonald Wright and Synchronism. South will speak to Macdonald-Wright’s place in the art world as well as the WPA program that enabled City Hall to be built. He curated an exhibition about Macdonald-Wright, which traveled to several locations, including LACMA in 2001.

Kim Morales Johnson, Vice President of the Gabrieleño/Tongva Springs Foundation, holds a number of distinguished positions representing the Gabrieleño/Tongva San Gabriel Band of Mission Indians. She and her family are active in Native American politics and culture and have been featured in documentaries and several books. She is a consultant and currently completing her Ph.D. in Native American studies at UC Davis. She also enjoys traditional basket weaving, preparing Native American foods, and keeping her culture alive.

Sharon Reyes is a descendant of Francisca Marquez and Maria Roque Valenzuela of the 1839 Mexican land grant, Rancho Boca de Santa Monica. Her ancestor’s name, Ysidro Reyes, is on the History mural at City Hall. Reyes researches and preserves archival material on her family history. With other land grant descendants, she was instrumental in preserving the Marquez Family Cemetery in Santa Monica Canyon. She is passionate about recognizing and protecting our cultural history.